The CRANAplus offices will be closed from midday Tuesday 24 December and will reopen on Thursday 2 January 2025. The CRANAplus Bush Support Line is available throughout the holidays and can be contacted at any time on 1300 805 391.

Equal opportunities needed for all health students

24 Mar 2022

Two thirds of nursing students never had the opportunity to complete a rural or remote placement, recent National Rural Health Student Network (NRHSN) research has shown. NRHSN Chair Jean-Baptiste Philibert MD IV WSU explores how our institutions can empower a greater number of students to go remote, for longer.

The Aus­tralian health care sys­tem expos­es its stu­dents to var­i­ous set­tings and loca­tions to best pre­pare them for the diver­si­ty of their future prac­tice. This includes cru­cial expo­sure to rur­al and remote practice. 

Unfor­tu­nate­ly, despite the best efforts of all involved, the COVID-19 pan­dem­ic has and con­tin­ues to dis­pro­por­tion­ate­ly affect the more remote place­ments of health stu­dents due to a vari­ety of fac­tors such as pro­tect­ing vul­ner­a­ble com­mu­ni­ties and bor­der closures. 

The North­ern Ter­ri­to­ry had some of the most dis­rupt­ed place­ments over that peri­od, yet pro­vides life-chang­ing expe­ri­ences, as I was lucky enough to expe­ri­ence in Ten­nant Creek in 2019 and Yuen­du­mu in 2020.

These place­ments are cru­cial for the future work­force of the Ter­ri­to­ry and all remote loca­tions in Aus­tralia. The lit­er­a­ture has shown that the longer the place­ment, to a dura­tion of up to three months in rur­al and remote Aus­tralia, the greater the like­li­hood the stu­dent will prac­tice rurally. 

Med­ical stu­dents, such as myself, are well sup­port­ed to expe­ri­ence long term place­ments in rur­al and remote areas via fund­ing pro­vid­ed to the Rur­al Clin­i­cal Schools (RCS) by the Rur­al Health Mul­ti­dis­ci­pli­nary Train­ing (RHMT) program.

These oppor­tu­ni­ties are, how­ev­er, spars­er to stu­dents study­ing non-med­ical cours­es, yet these pro­fes­sions are cru­cial to the future of rur­al and remote Aus­tralia and con­stant­ly fac­ing short­ages. Dis­ci­plines such as Nurs­ing, Phar­ma­cy and Audi­ol­o­gy only have place­ments in rur­al and remote set­tings of less than four weeks and none of the non-med­ical degrees have the oppor­tu­ni­ty for a long-term place­ment in rur­al and remote Aus­tralia (greater than six months). Fur­ther­more, the lit­er­a­ture demon­strates that often these stu­dents had to source and fund the place­ments themselves.

This is reflect­ed in a 2021 sur­vey from the NRHSN to its mem­bers on short-term rur­al place­ment oppor­tu­ni­ties. The NRHSN received over 500 respons­es, of which over 50% were by non-med­ical stu­dents. 87% of the sur­vey respon­dents were inter­est­ed in short-term place­ments in rur­al and remote set­tings. 33% of the sur­vey respon­dents had not had any expo­sure to rur­al health through their degree, increas­ing to 53% for nurs­ing stu­dents. Two-thirds of nurs­ing stu­dents nev­er had the oppor­tu­ni­ty to com­plete a rur­al and remote placement.

Sim­i­lar fig­ures were seen in Allied Health stu­dents. Of the stu­dents who had been on a short-term place­ment pro­gram, 85% intend­ed to work or train rural­ly, and the main fac­tor in influ­enc­ing them was their past place­ment in such settings.

These fig­ures demon­strate that rur­al intent is not nec­es­sar­i­ly fol­lowed through in non-med­ical stu­dents due to the lack of oppor­tu­ni­ties pro­vid­ed to them. This was con­firmed by the two main bar­ri­ers iden­ti­fied by these stu­dents, which were con­tacts to facil­i­tate place­ments (31%) and finan­cial bar­ri­ers (22%).

These are essen­tial­ly removed for med­ical stu­dents who take part in the extend­ed place­ments in rur­al and remote Aus­tralia through their RCS.

The sur­vey respon­dents saw an ide­al place­ment being between two to five weeks in length and regard­ed accom­mo­da­tion and finan­cial sup­port as a key com­po­nent of a suc­cess­ful place­ment. There is there­fore sig­nif­i­cant scope to remove the exist­ing bar­ri­ers that Nurs­ing, Mid­wifery and Allied Health stu­dents face for them expe­ri­ence all that rur­al and remote Aus­tralia has to offer.

The exist­ing oppor­tu­ni­ties such as the CRANAplus under­grad­u­ate schol­ar­ship are fan­tas­tic sup­port for these stu­dents but more can be done to remove the issues with sourc­ing place­ments, par­tic­u­lar­ly in the uncer­tain times we live in.

There­fore, the NRHSN is advo­cat­ing for the estab­lish­ment of a mul­ti­dis­ci­pli­nary pro­gram with repeat­ed lon­gi­tu­di­nal expo­sure for Nurs­ing, Mid­wifery and Allied Health stu­dents to expe­ri­ence life in rur­al and remote Aus­tralia beyond the con­straints of their degrees.

The 2022 NRHSN Exec­u­tive Group.

Why stu­dents applied or would apply for a pro­gram out­side of their university:

  • The great­est bar­ri­er as a first-gen­er­a­tion work­ing-class stu­dent was finan­cial, as not only are stu­dents sup­port­ing them­selves in the rur­al com­mu­ni­ty, but they are sac­ri­fic­ing time at work while away. The ide­al pro­gram would sup­port stu­dents financially.”
  • I applied as I craved rur­al expe­ri­ence, due to COVID-19 pre­vent­ing all pre-planned rur­al activ­i­ties through my uni­ver­si­ty… [I] want­ed an indi­vid­ual expe­ri­ence that would enable me to repli­cate the envi­ron­ment in which I could work in the future… sep­a­rate from the safe­ty of my uni­ver­si­ty friends, where it was just myself, the men­tor and the community.”
  • To get expe­ri­ence rural­ly, as I haven’t been offered rur­al expe­ri­ence through my rur­al clin­i­cal school despite mul­ti­ple applications.”
  • As I live in an out­er met­ro­pol­i­tan sub­urb of Ade­laide it was the only way to get an expe­ri­ence of more remote health.”

The Nation­al Rur­al Health Stu­dent Net­work (NRHSN) is the peak rep­re­sen­ta­tive body for med­ical, nurs­ing and allied health stu­dents who are pas­sion­ate about pur­su­ing careers in rur­al health. With over 11,000 mem­bers from 29 Rur­al Health Clubs (RHCs) across the coun­try, the NRHSN is one of Australia’s largest stu­dent organ­i­sa­tions in the health sec­tor. The NRHSN is an ini­tia­tive of the Aus­tralian Gov­ern­ment Depart­ment of Health, admin­is­tered by the Con­sor­tium of Rur­al Work­force Agen­cies (RWAs). The NSW Rur­al Doc­tors Net­work is the RWA man­ag­ing the NRHSN on behalf of the consortium.